Well Villa were expected to lose against Man United so we could've tried something different and experimented but McLeish went and put Heskey on up front. Slow, predictable and nothing that United haven't seen and dealt with before. I would've suggested to put Delfouneso on (a player who sadly does not get the chance he deserves and has been sent on loan once or twice since MON left). Having said that, he stuck with a 4-5-1 against United and Weimann was up there on his own. Agbonlahor has been off form for pretty much the whole season and he gets to wear the captain's armband? I don't see the logic in that. I would say the captaincy should've gone to Shay Given or Richard Dunne.
Then on Tuesday night McLeish played a 3-4-3 formation with Stephen Warnock on the left wing, deciding to experiment in a must win game.
With Bent, Dunne, Collins out, N'Zogbia, Agbonlahor, Hutton being awful this season and McLeish's over-reliance on Heskey (sometimes even playing him in midfield or out on the wing) it doesn't look good and the defensive mentality explains why we've dropped so many points. When Villa have gone 1-0 up they tend to sit back and go defensive. I hate that. Our problem for years has been that we are unable to finish teams off.
McLeish left Albrighton and Clarke out for a number of games earlier in the season which I seriously questioned as they were two of our best players last season and were doing okay this season. The best thing that happened to Villa this year was Robbie Keane; and Shay Given has been really good; Gary Gardner has been making good progress too.