Yes, rationally there is no difference between the arguments, but one will be respected whereas the other will get you branded a lunatic.
In discussions I sometimes use the same analogy he used with Poseidon. If people believe in a Christian God, I have the exact same amount of *rational* credibility if I say I believe in the pantheon of the Greek gods. Yet, such a belief will again be scoffed at.
And he raises a good point that we should stop being so careful around religious points just out of political correctness. Face the music, be open about this type of stuff. Just say out loud "THAT, is fucking ridiculous".
Also speaking of ridiculousness, as he points out, it's quite disturbing to find out 40% of the Electorate hold such unfounded yet respected beliefs. These are the people that might some day run the whole show, but they believe there's a fridge sized diamond in their backyard.